Brit + Co Logo

Turkey shouldn’t get to have all the fun.

16 Thanksgiving Proteins That Aren’t Turkey

Thanksgiving Proteins That Aren’t Turkey
Salt & Lavender

Sure, we all love the idea of a roasted turkey on Thanksgiving, but IRL, they’re usually overcooked, bland, and in need of a good dose of gravy to make up for their lackluster flavor. This year, think outside of the box and treat your friends and family to a stellar meal that will awaken their tastebuds! You’ve DIYed your own pie stand, you’ve created the perfect tablescape, and you’ve even worked extra hard on your place settings. You might as well make one of these main course dishes focused on Thanksgiving proteins (including some veggie options!) that are just as impressive as your decor.

Here are 16 delicious Thanksgiving protein ideas for anyone who doesn't like turkey.


Garlic roast beef

Life Tastes Good

Garlic Roast Beef

Feed a carnivorous army with this gorgeous garlic roast beef that is as juicy as it is flavorful. Slice this baby tableside, and your guests won’t be able to resist the aroma. (via Life Tastes Good)

Maple walnut crusted salmon

The Healthy Foodie

Maple Walnut Crusted Salmon

This salmon deserves a place front and center at your Thanksgiving table. Not only do you have the sweet maple glaze, but you also get a welcomed crunch from the walnut crust in this recipe. (via The Healthy Foodie)

Stuffed butternut squash with tempeh

Pickles and Honey

Stuffed Butternut Squash with Tempeh

This meatless (yet protein-packed) dish is a feast for your eyes and your mouth! It’s a vegan Thanksgiving treat that is almost too pretty to eat… almost. Bring this out of the oven and let the “oohs” and “ahhs” ensue. (via Pickles and Honey)

Beef Wellington with roast pumpkin,parsnip and mushrooms

What’s for Lunch, Honey?

Beef Wellington With Roast Pumpkin, Parsnip and Mushrooms

This luxe beef wellington is sure to impress even the classiest of Thanksgiving guests. Whip this up for your in-laws and your M.I.L. will be wrapped around your finger! (via What’s for Lunch, Honey?)

Cranberry apple stuffed Cornish hens

Running to the Kitchen

Cranberry Apple Stuffed Cornish Hens

If you’re having a small Thanksgiving gathering this year, go with some Cornish game hens. Everyone gets their own bird, which makes for a beautiful presentation, and this recipe is even stuffed with fresh cranberries and apples! (via Running to the Kitchen)

Creamy mushroom pork tenderloin

Salt & Lavender

Creamy Mushroom Pork Tenderloin

Time is of the essence during the holidays, so a hearty main dish is as precious as gold. Plus, if there’s a delicious gravy involved, it’s already a hit. This creamy mushroom pork tenderloin will be gone faster than it took you to make it! (via Salt & Lavender)

Herb crusted lamb chops

The Gourmet Gourmand

Herb Crusted Lamb Chops

Have someone you’re trying to impress this Thanksgiving? Break out these herb-crusted lamb chops and you’ll be considered a T-Day queen for many years to come! (via The Gourmet Gourmand)

Chickpea vegan meatloaf

Connoisseurus Veg

Chickpea Vegan Meatloaf

Sure, meatloaf isn’t quite a traditional Thanksgiving main course, but with a sweet maple tomato glaze, it sure fits the bill flavor-wise. (via Connoisseurus Veg)

1 hour vegan pot pies

Minimalist Baker

1-Hour Vegan Pot Pies

These individual pot pies are so adorable and full of rich flavor, no one will even notice they’re vegan. Plus, who doesn’t love getting their own little dish of food? (via Minimalist Baker)

Slow Cooker Pineapple Honey Mustard Ham

Serena Bakes Simply from Scratch

Slow Cooker Pineapple Honey Mustard Ham

Ham isn’t only for Christmas, people. This juicy pineapple-glazed ham is perfect for any holiday meal. Bonus: it’s made in the slow cooker, which frees up tons of vital oven space. (via Serena Bakes Simply from Scratch)

Vegetarian lentil and butternut squash Wellington

Vikalinka

Vegetarian Lentil & Butternut Squash Wellington

In case you need to feed an entire crew of plant-based eaters, opt for this veggie spin on a crowd favorite. There’s no need to sacrifice a hearty main course when you have awesome alternative Thanksgiving proteins like these. (via Vikalinka)
Cranberry Meatballs

Pink Owl Kitchen

Cranberry Meatballs

These little spheres of flavor are a burst of savory and sweet, with a tangy cranberry glaze that's downright addictive. Forget the gravy – these meatballs will be the saucy stars of your Thanksgiving spread! (via Pink Owl Kitchen)

Grilled Lamb Chops

Feel Good Foodie

Grilled Lamb Chops

These lamb chops, perfectly seasoned and seared, bring a touch of elegance to your table. This is the premier choice for a feast fit for royalty. (via Feel Good Foodie)

Dutch Oven Whole Roast Chicken

Bowl of Delicious

Dutch Oven Whole Roast Chicken

Succulent, juicy, and infused with a medley of herbs, this bird takes center stage in a cast iron pot. Your Thanksgiving guests will be clucking about this chicken long after the last bite. (via Bowl of Delicious)

Roasted Vegetable Wellington

This Wife Cooks

Roasted Vegetable Wellington

Imagine a golden puff pastry hugging a medley of roasted veggies, herbs, and savory goodness. It's like a Thanksgiving hug for your taste buds – a vegetarian delight that even carnivores will crave. (via This Wife Cooks)

Butternut Squash & Spinach Lasagna

Cozy Cravings

Butternut Squash & Spinach Lasagna

Layers of velvety butternut goodness dance with sautéed spinach, ricotta, and mozzarella, creating a symphony of flavors that'll have your guests singing your culinary praises. This is comfort food elevated to a whole new level. (via Cozy Cravings)

Subscribe to our newsletter for more Thanksgiving recipe ideas!

This post has been updated.

The Conversation (1)
Reviews: (1)
Sort by
Beck & Bulow
Beck & Bulow
17 Nov, 2021
Review:

Thanks for sharing such healthy and yummy health ideas for thanksgiving day. This is one of the best articles I have crossed. I also came across one more idea that you can also wish to visit for more options Click Here: https://www.beckandbulow.com

Selfmade

Selfmade

A business accelerator for early-stage female founders with live workshops, 1:1 mentoring, online courses, and curated business support. Visit

Yap City

Yap City

Want the inside scoop on what’s really trending? Join insider hosts Chloe Williams and Kayla Walden each week as they dissect their latest TV & movie obsessions, must-read books, and OMG moments you won’t believe. Visit