Katie Bouman Is a STEM Hero — But Not for the Reason We Thought

Kelli Korducki
Apr 12, 2019

A few hours after the world (by way of the internet) laid eyes on the very first photographic image of a black hole, the name “Katie Bouman” began trending. According to a tweet from the MIT Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Lab, the 29-year-old MIT postdoctoral student had “led the creation of a new algorithm” that made the black hole image possible. After the pic went public on Wednesday, it wasn’t long before another photo began making the rounds: one of the fresh-faced scientist posed in front of a computer screen that displayed the groundbreaking image she’d helped create, with her hands clasped over her mouth in proud disbelief.

In an instant, Bouman became a stand-in for generations of women scientists whose contributions to technological breakthroughs were buried under the names of their male colleagues. Celebrities tweeted in appreciation. Others listed the names of female scientists that time, and sexism, had allowed us to forget. The moment felt triumphant: a chance for women in STEM to get their long-deserved moment in the spotlight. But there was also some pushback against this simple, feel-good version of events — namely, from Katie Bouman herself.

“I’m so excited that we finally get to share what we have been working on for the past year!” she wrote on Facebook. “The image shown today is the combination of images produced by multiple methods. No one algorithm or person made this image, it required the amazing talent of a team of scientists from around the globe and years of hard work to develop the instrument, data processing, imaging methods, and analysis techniques that were necessary to pull off this seemingly impossible feat. It has been truly an honor, and I am so lucky to have had the opportunity to work with you all.”

In fact, Bouman was one of more than 200 scientists from 60 different research institutions, in 18 countries across six continents, to contribute to the project. Approximately 40 women (including Bouman) were involved.

While many media outlets (including us) mistakenly reported that Bouman had led the creation of the algorithm used to visualize the previously unphotographable image, a Harvard astronomer named Shep Doeleman was actually in charge of the project.

Bouman’s contributions were important to this process, and while it’s true that she led a team in developing an algorithm intended to create an image of a black hole, the New York Times reported Thursday that Bouman’s algorithm was not the one ultimately used to make the photo we saw on Wednesday. (On Friday afternoon, the MIT CSAIL Twitter account issued a series of posts to clear up earlier confusion.)

“There are women involved in every single step of this amazing project,” said Sara Issaoun, a 24-year-old graduate student at Radboud University in the Netherlands, in an interview with the Times. Issaoun was one of the researchers involved.

So, it appears that many of us got the details of this story a bit wrong, and the reasons why are pretty straightforward. Obviously, it’s easy to jump to less-than-accurate conclusions from information that’s shared on social media, especially in celebration of a young woman for a breakthrough in STEM, a field in which women are so notoriously underrepresented.

The Bouman story was also the product of our tendency to credit individual thought-leaders or “pioneers” for making change happen. We like being able to point to a single person who made a difference in the world, because it inspires us to try to do the same. But the truth is that no one person alone is responsible for making big things happen.

Collaboration is a superpower. As Katie Bouman wants us to remember, it’s when we work together that the impossible comes within reach — or, in the case of black holes, that the unphotographable becomes photographed. The Bouman story is one of teamwork and triumph, and by upholding that spirit, more of us will be able to shine. It may not be the story we wanted, but it’s the one with the most to offer.

RELATED: The Black Hole Photo Everyone’s Freaking Out About Was Made Possible by This Female Grad Student

(Photo by Dursun Aydemir/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images)

11 Binge-Worthy New November Shows We're Already Obsessed With

More times than not, I often find myself perusing the various television show options on Netflix, Hulu, Max and other streaming services, desperately trying to find a new TV show to watch, but to no avail. Luckily, a new month is right around the corner, which means there are a handful of new binge-worthy shows that have yet to be released and will certainly keep us all entertained. Whether you’re looking for an enticing new drama (like Peacock’s The Day of the Jackal) or a returning series (like Outer Banks Season 4 Part 2 on Netflix), here are 11 must-watch television shows coming out in November 2024. And make sure you're caught up on the 9 New October TV Shows We’ve Been Waiting For All Year!

'Love Is Blind: Argentina' — On Netflix November 6

Mayra Ortiz/Netflix

Prepare to re-enter the pods because Netflix’s Love Is Blind is headed to Argentia! Back in January of this year, Netflix confirmed Argentina would be the next destination for the popular dating show, with Wanda Nara and Darío Barassi serving as hosts. And did we mention this latest adaptation is set to premiere one week after the Love Is Blind season 7 reunion? Say less.

Love Is Blind: Argentina will be hosted by Wanda Nara and Darío Barassi.

'The Day of the Jackal'  — On Peacock November 7

Peacock

Based on the 1971 classic novel by author Frederick Forsyth, The Day of the Jackal is a new thriller series thatfollows an skilled assassin named “The Jackal” (Eddie Redmayne), who makes a lucrative living by “carrying out hits for the highest fee,” per the show’s official synopsis. But after his latest kill puts British intelligence officer (Lashana Lynch) on his heels, they begin "a thrilling cat-and-mouse chase across Europe, leaving destruction in its wake.” Honestly, you had us at Eddie Redmayne and Lashana Lynch.

The ensemble cast of The Day of the Jackal features Eddie Redmayne, Lashana Lynch, Úrsula Corberó, Charles Dance, Richard Dormer, Chukwudi Iwuji, Lia Williams, Khalid Abdalla, Eleanor Matsuura, Jonjo O’Neill, Nick Blood, Sule Rimi and Florisa Kamara.

'Outer Banks' Season 4 Part 2 — On Netflix November 7

Jackson Lee Davis/Netflix

The treasure hunt is far from over! As the Pogues embark on a new journey to uncover the long-lost treasure of the infamous Blackbeard, their future is riddled with so much uncertainty. Last time we saw the OBX crew was in the Outer Banks season 4 part 1 finale, which left Sarah and Pope trapped in a crypt with no possible escape, John B. and Cleo battling it out with Lightener, and JJ discovering he’s been a Kook all along (!!!).

With so many unanswered questions and a myriad of challenges plaguing the Pogues' latest endeavor, it’s hard to know what comes next for the friend group. But no matter what, they will always have each other. #P4L.

Outer Banks season 4 part 2 will feature members of its main cast, including Chase Stokes, Madelyn Cline, Madison Bailey, Jonathan Daviss, Rudy Pankow, Carlacia Grant, Drew Starkey and Austin North.

'Citadel: Honey Bunny' - On Prime Video November 7

Prime Video

Before Priyanka Chopra’s Nadia Sinh became the lethal assassin we know and love, her parents—Honey and Bunny—first crossed paths years prior. While working as a stuntman, Bunny recruits down-on-her-luck actress Honey for a dangerous side gig. As their past threatens to catch up to them, Honey and Bunny vow to protect their daughter, Nadia, and keep her out of harm’s way.

Serving as a spinoff to Prime Video’s Citadel, this upcoming action-packed series is set to star a bunch of new faces, including Samantha Ruth Prabhu, Varun Dhawan, Emma Canning and Sikandar Kher.

'Bad Sisters' Season 2 — On Apple TV+ November 13

Apple TV+

Following the unexpected death of their parents and Grace's abusive husband, all eyes are, once again, on the Garvey sisters, who appear more guilty than ever. As secrets from their past threaten to resurface, the siblings must navigate the lies and suspicions that could upend their lives as they know it. Take it from us: This dark comedy is an absolute must-watch.

Bad Sisters season 2 brings back Sharon Horgan, Anne-Marie Duff, Eva Birthistle, Sarah Greene and Eve Hewson as the Garvey sisters in addition to newcomers Fiona Shaw, Owen McDonnell, Thaddea Graham, Deirdre Mullins, Lorcan Cranitch, Liz Fitzgibbon and Justine Mitchell.

'Cobra Kai' Season 6 Part 2 — On Netflix November 15

Netflix

Pack your bags, fellow students, because Miyagi-Do is catching a flight to Barcelona, Spain, to compete in the Sekai Taikai tournament! The stakes have never been higher for our favorite dojo, which is something the Cobra Kai co-creator Jon Hurwitz wanted to convey in this final installment of the Karate Kid sequel series.

While talking with Tudum, Hurwitz shared that the second half of season six will be the “most combustible” throughout the show’s run. He added, “You get to meet new, exciting characters and take all of our combustible characters, and you get to see karate outside of the Valley. How are they going to handle the pressure? How are they going to handle being in the most intense karate fight of their lives while it’s not harmonious between them?”

'Dune: Prophecy' — On Max November 17

Attila Szvacsek/HBO

10,000 years before we meet Timothee Chalemet’s Paul Atreides and Zendaya's Chani (and before they meet each other), two Harkonnen sisters are fighting tooth and nail to save the future of humanity. As war and political discord threatens everything they know, they turn their "unassuming" women's school into the powerful Bene Gesserit.

The amazing Dune: Prophecy cast includes Emily Watson, Olivia Williams, Travis Fimmel, Jodhi May, Mark Strong, Sarah-Sofie Boussnina, Josh Heuston, Chloe Lea, Jade Anouka, Faoileann Cunningham, Edward Davis, Aoife Hinds, Chris Mason, Shalom Brune-Franklin, Camilla Beeput, Jihae, Tabu, Charithra Chandran, Jessica Barden, Emma Canning, and Yerin Ha.

'Interior Chinatown' — On Hulu November 19

Mike Taing/Disney

Meet Willis Wu, a struggling background character trapped inside a police show who dreams of a life beyond waiting tables in Chinatown. However, his life takes a turn for the worse when he accidentally witnesses a crime and the police turn to him for help. Soon, Willis uncovers an underground conspiracy and learns how his family’s past ties into everything in this November TV show inspired by Charles Yu's award-winning novel of the same name.

Interior Chinatown stars Jimmy O. Yang, Ronny Chieng, Chloe Bennet, Sullivan Jones, Lisa Gilroy and Diana Lin.

'Cruel Intentions' - Premiers on Prime Video on November 21

Jasper Savage/Prime Video

Based on the 1999 film starring Reese Witherspoon, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Ryan Phillippe and Selma Blair (and inspired by Pierre Choderlos de Laclos’ 1782 Les Liaisons Dangereuses), this reboot follows a new generation of two upper-class step-siblings named Catherine Hook and Lucien Valmont, who practically run Manchester College’s Greek scene. When a hazing incident threatens to eradicate all fraternity and sorority activities on campus, they devise a plan for Annie Grover, daughter of the Vice President of the United States — who also happens to be enrolled at the university.

Prime Video’s Cruel Intentions stars Sarah Catherine Hooks, Zac Burgess, Savannah Lee Smith in addition to Sara Silva, John Harlan Kim, Khobe Clarke, Brooke Lena Johnson and Sean Patrick Thomas, who (fun fact!) portrayed Ronald in the original Cruel Intentions film.

'The Sex Lives of College Girls' Season 3 — On Max November 21

Katrina Marcinowski/HBO Max

Is it getting hot in here, or is it just us? The Sex Lives of College Girls is back with a third season, and based on the trailer, it appears that this installment is gearing up to be quite…steamy! Though Kimberly (Pauline Chalamet), Bela (Amrit Kaur), Leighton (Reneé Rapp) and Whitney (Alyah Chanelle Scott) are returning for another semester at Essex College, the college roommates will soon have to figure out a new living situation. Yes, that’s right: Back in July 2023, Rapp announced that she will leave the show after season three.

At the time, Rapp shared on social media: “College Girls moved me out to LA and introduced me to some of my favorite people. 2 and a half years later—it’s given me y’all and this community. Thank you Mindy, Justin and everyone at Max for believing in me. A lot of queer works gets belittled — but playing Leighton has changed my life. I love who I am 10x more than I did before knowing her. I hope she gave y'all a little bit of that too. She's such a tiny part of the representation but even the tiny parts count. I wouldn’t be half the person I am without her and y’all. I’m so excited for this season and I can’t wait for you to see what we have coming for her and the girls.”

We’re going to miss you, Leighton :(

The Sex Lives of College Girls season 3 stars Pauline Chalamet, Amrit Kaur, Reneé Rapp, Alyah Chanelle Scott, Devin Craig, Ruby Cruz, Michael Provost, Roby Attal, and Mitchell Slaggert.

'Based on a True Story' Season 2 — On Peacock on November 21

Colleen Hayes/Peacock

Who’s ready for round two of Peacock’s Based on a True Story? This time around, Ava and Nathan Bartlett are trying to navigate their lives as new parents. As they try to leave Matt (AKA “The Westside Ripper”) and their podcast days behind them, there's a new serial killer wreaking havoc across Los Angeles. And being the true crime-obsessed fan that she is, Ava's already on the case and she has her first suspect: Matt, who also happens to be her sister’s new fiancé.

Can Ava and Nathan uncover the identity of the new killer before they strike again? Or will they soon become the murderer’s next target? Well, we do know one thing: November 21 can’t come soon enough.

Based on a True Story season 2 stars Kaley Cuoco, Chris Messina, Tom Bateman, Liana Liberato, and Melissa Fumero.

Which new November TV show are you looking forward to? Let us know in the comments and get the latest weekend watch updates on our weekend newsletter. While you're at it, We Know You Know The 3 Beverage Rule. Here's The 3 TV Show Rule.

pop cultureouter banksduneentertainment

Gisele Bündchen Pregnancy News "Stunned" Tom Brady: "Never Imagined"

Gisele Bündchen is a household name, no matter who her partner is — but it's no secret the supermodel made waves when she split from her football star husband, Tom Brady, in 2022. It's clear she's not holding on to the past, though. After dating Joaquim Valente for the past two years, the couple is officially expecting their first child together! Here's everything we know about Gisele's growing family!

Is Gisele Bündchen pregnant?

Michael Loccisano/Getty Images for Gaia Herbs

Yes! According to PEOPLE, an inside source told the outlet that the 44-year-old supermodel is officially expecting her third child. This is her first baby with current boyfriend, Joaquim Valente. The source said, "Gisele and Joaquim are happy for this new chapter in their life and they're looking forward to creating a peaceful and loving environment for the whole family."

Who is Gisele Bündchen's boyfriend?

Instagram/gisele

Joaquim Valente is a jiu-jitsu professional at his family-owned studio, Valente Brothers. The 34-year-old continues a decades-long tradition of teaching this martial art to future generations — and his girlfriend!

These two have been linked together since 2022, but didn't start officially dating until June 2023 according to PEOPLE. In 2024, a source also told PEOPLE that this wasn't "a serious love affair," but the tides have clearly turned since then.

In March 2024, Gisele The New York Times, “This is the first time I am seeing someone that was a friend of mine first." She then noted, “It’s very different. It is very honest, and it’s very transparent.” She also was quick to deny that there was any overlap with her ex-husband, stressing that these types of rumors happen "to a lot of women" who "have the courage to leave an unhealthy relationship."

As for the most current state of Gisele and Joaquim's relationship? A source told Page Six, “Their chemistry together has always been there and they have a lot in common. They've been in love for a while." That being said, sources also told Page Sixthat they don't think the pair will get married "anytime soon." Despite Gisele being "thrilled" to welcome another child, her friends tell the outlet that the couple will just "live together for now."

Regardless, we're also thrilled for these two, and we hope their new child brings them so much joy!

How many kids does Gisele Bündchen have?

Instagram/gisele

Gisele Bündchen and Tom Brady have two children together — Bejamin Rein (14) and Vivian Lake (11). According to Page Six, a source says that these two "really like" Joaquim Valente, as he's been living with them in Miami "for a while." We just know these two will be fabulous siblings to the new little one, given the way they show so much love to their parents!

When did Gisele Bündchen and Tom Brady get divorced?

Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images for The Met Museum/Vogue

Gisele Bündchen and Tom Brady officially divorced in 2022. However, according to Page Six, this all started back in 2020 when Tom wouldn't retire from the NFL — and according to a source from PEOPLE, their problems date back as long as 10 years! Regardless, it's clear Gisele's moved on to a new chapter in her life. Good for her!

Has Tom Brady said anything about Gisele Bündchen's new pregnancy?

Instagram/tombrady

While sources told TMZthat Gisele Bündchen told Tom Brady about her pregnancy before the news broke to the general public, other sources told Page Sixthat he only just found out "very recently" — and apparently, he didn't find out from Gisele. Sources explained to Page Six that the ex-spouses "talk when they have to." So I guess this situation didn't exactly qualify as having to talk...

Still, a source close to the situation explained to Page Six that Tom was "stunned" to find out about the news. “Tom knew that things were serious between Gisele and Joaquin but he never imagined they would be having a child together,” they said. "“It just wasn’t something that was on his radar. So when Gisele broke the news to him he was stunned, to say the least.”

Tom hasn't made an official statement about Gisele's pregnancy, but he did take to Instagram on October 28. The former football star posted an image of the sunset, three hearts, and The Chicks' cover of "Landslide." The Stevie Nicks original is all about the changes life brings, so Tom's seemingly alluding to the changes coming in his own life.

And that same Page Sixsource noted that Tom's “grown used to the idea and he’s happy for Gisele.” They said, “At the end of the day, Tom’s sole focus is on his children and his career. What Gisele decides to do with her own life is really none of his business.”

Whatever happens next, we hope that this modern family navigates this new chapter with grace and love!

Looking for more celebrity news? Be sure to follow us on Facebook so you never miss a thing!

This post has been updated.

celebritiescelebrity couplestom bradycelebrity news

The One Reason Zoë Kravitz And Channing Tatum's Engagement "Fizzled"

Zoë Kravitz and Channing Tatum made headlines for their whirlwind romanceafter they met while making Zoë's directorial debutBlink Twice. Fans were so excited to learn they were engaged, but on October 29, multiple sources reported that the couple had broken up — and called off their upcoming wedding. Here's a look back at their relationship timeline.

Zoë Kravitz And Channing Tatum's Relationship Timeline

Image via Michael Loccisano/Getty Images

February 10, 2017 — The Lego Batman Movie Premieres

Glimmers of their love story began in 2017 when Zoë Kravitz and Channing Tatum lent their voices to the hit animated film, The Lego Batman Movie. Little did they know that this animated connection would pave the way for their real-life love story a few years later.

Image via Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty Images for ABA

Summer 2021 — Zoë Kravitz And Channing Tatum Work Together Again

Kravitz was all set to work with Tatum in her directorial debut film P*ssy Island. This creative endeavor brought the two closer, both personally and professionally, setting the stage for a unique partnership. While working on the film, Tatum advised Kravitz not to take on too much, showcasing the supportive and collaborative nature of their relationship. Both stars had nothing but praise for each other's work and creativity.

Image via Neilson Barnard/Getty Images

August 2021 — Zoë Kravitz Gets A Fresh Start

At the start of 2021, Zoë Kravitz divorced her former spouse, eventually sparking rumors a possible romance with Channing Tatum. This marked the potential for the beginning of their exciting journey as a couple, with their personal lives becoming increasingly intertwined. August was a pivotal month for these two, too. Channing Tatum showed his love and support by following various fan-run Instagram accounts dedicated to Zoë Kravitz. It wasn't long before their relationship made its way into the public eye. And hello, did you see that Brooklyn bike ride? It was clear this couple was meant-to-be kinda cute from the beginning!

Images via Theo Wargo/Getty Images/Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images for The Met Museum/Vogue

September 13, 2021 — Zoë Kravitz And Channing Tatum Make Their Red Carpet Debut

The couple made their debut — stepping up and out at the iconic Met Gala, a night filled with glamour and romance. Their joint appearance in multiple after party pictures confirmed their blossoming relationship to the world. Kravitz wore a sexy chain dress, while Tatum looked incredibly handsome in a black tux.

Image via Joe Maher/Getty Images

November 15, 2022 — Zoë Kravitz Calls Her Relationship With Channing Tatum "Sacred"

In a GQ interview, Zoë Kravitz opened up about her relationship with Tatum. She shared that they chose to keep their love story relatively low-key, wanting to keep it sacred and private for as long as possible. “He’s just a wonderful human," she says. "He makes me laugh and we both really love art and talking about art and the exploration of why we do what we do. We love to watch a film and break it down and talk about it and challenge each other."

“You want to keep it sacred and private as long as you can,” Kravitz continues. “So that you don’t have to even think about what the world thinks about it.”

Image via Jeff Spicer/Getty Images for Paramount Pictures

January 17, 2023 — Channing Tatum Says He's A "Monogamist"

Channing Tatum candidly discussed the early days of his relationship with Zoë Kravtiz in Vanity Fair, revealing they briefly lost touch before rekindling their connection on the set of P*ssy Island. He also opened up about his struggles in matters of the heart.

“Relationships are hard for me,” Channing says. “I am a bit of a monogamist...but heart things, when it comes to people I love, I have a really hard time. I end up trying too hard, you know?”

Image via Ilya S. Savenok/Getty Images for Kering

June 2023 — Zoë Kravitz And Channing Tatum Are Taking Things Slowly

Sources close to the couple revealed to US Weeklythat Zoë Kravitz and Channing Tatum were in no hurry to get engaged, as both had experienced failed marriages before. "They are perfectly happy with where things are and cherish [their] special relationship," the source says. "Having a baby is a very real possibility. But they enjoy taking things slowly."

Images via Emma McIntyre/Getty Images for Academy Museum of Motion Pictures/Amy Sussman/Getty Images

October 31, 2023 — Zoë Kravitz And Channing Tatum Are Engaged!

After a romantic date night in Paris during Fashion Week, Zoë Kravitz and Channing Tatum are getting married! In October, the lovebirds finally took the next step and got engaged, per PEOPLE, promising a future filled with love and adventure. YAY! We love love!

www.instagram.com

January 26, 2024 — Channing Tatum Supports Zoë Kravitz' New Movie

Channing recently took to Instagram to show his support of Zoë directing Blink Twice (formerly named P*ssy Island) and even shared a cute BTS video of them looking intently at a scene being filmed. "MISS DIRECTOR LADY HERSELF IN ACTION!!" he says in the caption. "ABSOLUTELY CRUSHING IT. CAN’T WAIT FOR YALL TO SEE."

Image via Ilya S. Savenok/Getty Images for Kering

March 4, 2024 — Zoë Kravitz And Channing Tatum Are Doing "Fantastic"

"Channing and Zoë are doing fantastic and could not be more in love," a source tells ET. "They’re so thrilled about their engagement and to be taking this next step together." The fact that *they're* excited about their engagement makes *me* even more excited for them!

August 9, 2024 — Zoë Kravitz And Channing Tatum Attend The Blink Twice Premiere

Look out world because Zoë Kravitz and Channing Tatum have officially stepped out on the red carpet together! They stunned in gorgeous, minimalistic black ensembles at the premiere of Blink Twice and made us wish we could've been specks of dust on what they were wearing.

Zoë wore a satin Saint Laurent dress and kept the rest of her look simple while Channing took dapper to the next level with a tailored black suit. Honestly, this is one sexy couple whose engagement rumors we hope are true.

Rodin Eckenroth/Getty Images

August 14, 2024 — Lenny Kravitz Is Excited For Zoë's Wedding

Fans may be surprised to know Zoë Kravtiz and Channing Tatum didn't know each other before she shared her idea for Blink Twice. Spending time together snowballed into the romantic relationship they have today, but wedding bells aren't ringing soon. Though her dad, Lenny Kravitz announced he's excited for the couple's wedding (via Entertainment Tonight), Zoë admitted that she and Channing have talked about it "in passing," (via Esquire).

Also, you might want to erase the image of Zoë being a mother from your brain because she doesn't think she'll be taking on that role. It's something she used to be scared to admit, but feels more comfortable talking about these days (via Esquire).

"There’s a lot of pressure on women to have children, and there’s a feeling that if you don’t, you don’t have purpose here. But this movie, it feels like I gave birth," she said.

October 29, 2024 — Zoë Kravitz And Channing Tatum Have Broken Up

Multiple sources told People that Channing Tatum and Zoë Kravitz have split after three years together, and called off their wedding. TMZ also confirmed the news.

“Wedding plans were looming, but neither of them were rushing to the altar,” a source told Us Weekly, adding that their relaxed mindset ended up putting "a lot of pressure" on them. “Ultimately once [Blink Twice] ended, they realized they were on different pages with what they wanted. It fizzled fast after their press tour wrapped.”

​What are Channing Tatum & Zoë Kravitz ages?

Gareth Cattermole/Getty Images

Channing Tatum was born on April 26, 1980, making him 43 years old. Zoë Kravitz (who's 35 years old) was born on December 1, 1988, so there's an 8-year age gap between the two.

Looking for more celeb news? Be sure to sign up for our email newsletter and if you love Zoë Kravitz and Channing Tatum's relationship, check out the latest news on Tom Holland And Zendaya and Taylor Swift And Travis Kelce!

Header image via Rodin Eckenroth/Getty Images

This post has been updated.

best readscelebritycelebrity newsengagement announcementevergreenpop culturerelationshipcelebrity couples